Taiwan Journal of Linguistics

A Diamond Open Access Journal (free to authors and readers)
ISSN: 1729-4649 (print); 1994-2559 (online)

ON THE TWO DISCOURSE CONNECTIVES FǑUZÉ AND BÙRÁN IN MANDARIN CHINESE: AN SDRT ACCOUNT

Jiun-Shiung Wu / National Chung Cheng University
This paper argues that fǒuzé and bùrán have a modal-like semantics and furthermore that their semantics need to be modelled by means of Segmented Discourse Representation Theory, because they involve discourse structure and rhetorical relations. Given a discourse π1, fǒuzé/bùrán π2, where π1 and π2 are clauses, π2 is interpreted given ¬π1. These two discourse connectives realize the following discourse effects. First, they introduce ¬π1 into the discourse, represented as a Segmented Discourse Representation Structure. Second, ¬π1 and π1, where the latter is present in the discourse but the former is not, show a contrastive relationship. Third, either that π2 is a result of ¬π1 or that π1 and π2 are alternatives, depending on whether it is fǒuzé or bùrán and whether ¬π1 and π2 has a (loose) causal relationship. In addition, a few more details are under discussion, e.g. which clause is negated when π1 consists of two clauses, what role the set of propositions where ¬π1 is true play when π1 is a question or an imperative, how huòzhě ‘or’ on the one hand and dànshì/kěshì ‘but’ on the other differ from fǒuzé/bùrán. Finally, the differences between these two connectives are presented.

論漢語的兩個篇章連詞「否則、否然」 片段篇章表述理論的解釋

吳俊雄 / 國立中正大學
本文論證,「否則、不然」的語意類似情態詞,且需以片段篇章表述理論才能模擬,因為,此二者與篇章結構與修辭關係有關。假設有一個篇章:π1, 否則/不然 π2,π1、π2 是子句,π2 必須在¬π1的情況下才能得到詮釋。此二篇章連詞實現下面的篇章功效:一、將¬π1引介進入片段篇章表述結構中;二、¬π1 、π1以對比關係做連結;(三) π2與¬π1 以結果關係做連結,或,π1、π2以二選一這個修辭關係連結。由哪個修辭關係做連結,視句子中包含「否則」或「不然」及π1與π2間是否有寬鬆的因果關係而定。另外,也討論幾個細節:(一) 當π1由兩個以上的子句組成時,¬π1是哪個子句被否定;(二) ¬π1為真的可能世界,在π2為問句或祈使用時,扮演角色為何;(三) 「或者」、「但是、可是」與「否則、不然」的差異。最後則討論「否則、不然」的差別為何。